Enter Amount:

Quotes

All men dream: but not equally. Those who dream by night in the dusty recesses of their minds wake in the day to find that it was vanity: but the dreamers of the day are dangerous men, for they may act their dream with open eyes, to make it possible.    T. E. Lawrence (1888 - 1935), "The Seven Pillars of Wisdom"


Content View Hits : 3072653
Carrying within a campus on Shabath PDF Print E-mail
Written by Webmaster   
Tuesday, 29 June 2010 18:10
Carrying within a campus on Shabath

Question:
Can I carry on Shabbos in a fenced-in campus, where the front gate is always left open?
There are two other gates that are open on weekdays, but are locked at night and on Shabbos/Chagim.
The front gate is never closed. It is open 24/7.

Answer:
1.    According to some Pos’qim (Rashba, ‘Avodath HaQodhesh, Beth N’thivoth 3:1; Hakham Ssvi 37 et al), the campus has the status of R'shuth HaRabim due to the open areas where people gather within the campus, similar to a town square. According to this view, carrying within the open areas is asur min haTora.
2.    Even discounting this view, Rambam (MT ‘Eruvin 1:1) and others hold that the campus fence would render it a R'shuth HaYahidh only if all gates are closed at night.
3.    Even if it is R'shuth HaYahidh, an 'Eruv is required to be able to carry there. For a number of reasons I am not at all sure that this is feasible. Others who live on campus, non-Jews or secular Jews, would have to m'vattel or rent their "r'shuth" to you or someone representing all the religious Jews. This might be achieved if the university authorities were willing to sign off on such a thing. Frankly, I doubt it.
4.    Have you asked the campus rabbi about this? He may know something regarding the facts that I don't.

Rabbi David Bar-Hayim
Last Updated on Tuesday, 29 June 2010 18:14